LMarbles: mechanical Quit reserve, original Puzzle8 clear, Puzzle9 denied

Run: scratch/runs/20261114-lmarbles-reserved-puzzle8/.

Puzzle8 cleared after 62 individually reviewed, manually delivered settled slides: Moves96 → Moves34, native bonus tally2700, green eighth selector dot. The tally continuation returned to Puzzle1 at score2700. Selecting the first dot in row2 (the ninth puzzle) displayed Access Denied. Puzzle9 entry/clear is unproved; no locked-level bypass, state import, second original, or campaign completion claim follows. Full27 remains unproved. Ordinary native Escape → reviewed Y → reviewed setup Escape exited with guest [Exit] code=0 and actual harness wait0.

Durable controller and regression scope

New tools/lmarbles-controller.py adopts the exact prior tested pointer helper SHA256 54508b765ea1499c403cfb109168057bb5704a7d4d7b68e65ff62607ea5de3f5. The prior recovered supervisor SHA256 is 57ae4c3032e1b6b85536c0b72e57cc3a194fff10d9f236affd58bf5069f29331. New tools/lmarbles-supervisor.py persists runtimeDeadline and the immutable gameplayCutoff = runtimeDeadline - 180 before starting the original. The controller checks that relationship and creation time. It checks intent before a lease, before independent release-child arm, and immediately before each DOWN; the production guard deadline is also clamped to the gameplay cutoff. An action whose complete operation window would cross the cutoff is refused before arm. Crossing the cutoff permanently enters Quit phase. Gameplay is the default; slides, selection and motion cannot be silently renamed Quit.

Explicit Quit intents permanently enter Quit phase even earlier. They accept only individually reviewed ordinary Escape/Y route choices, with the route bound in that fresh capture's review. No automatic Quit sequence exists. Permanent ownership, unique nonces, guard implementation and noReplay remain. Direct loopback /ctl is checked against the actual native PID/start token and listening socket. No relay or rebind is used. A separate release child is armed before DOWN with an immutable two-second cap; consumed-time release scheduling and actual transport-return ACK timing are preserved. LateACK/UNKNOWN remain terminal, with independent UP attempted and no replay. Final owner-exit evidence requires matching actual normal native wait and both EOFs; it never fabricates a physical UP ACK or guest Quit. This original obtained actual UP ACK for all110.

Exact new tests and fixture:

First-press boundary: a56 is not universal

The prior run's correct SDL coordinates with stale game.lastMotion are a real counterexample to claiming a56 universally fixes first selection. The new public SDL consumer keeps the pointer at140,150 across SDL_SetVideoMode; SDL delivers the ordinary button without zero-delta motion. A genuine distinct move to160,170 emits SDL motion and the following ordinary button works. This fixture exercises a public video transition in one SDL window; it does not model every internal LMarbles phase or prove a separate operating-system implementation behaves the same. No emulator divergence warranting another runtime patch was established. No forced-hover72590, queue-only candidate, synthetic native hover-state write, or game patch was restored.

In this original, a personally reviewed, ordinary distinct mousemove into the board preceded the first blue selection. Read-only inspection then showed both SDL and game.lastMotion327,95 (screen350,138); the subsequent first selection worked. This is a legitimate input workaround, not a universal a56-fix claim.

Bounded original and lifecycle

Coordinator17:56:27 explicitly reordered the already-active Forsaken validation before reserved LMarbles, followed by LBreakout. No overlap or old-window extension occurred. This sole new fixed1800s run began17:57:55.122Z with an independent1820s watchdog prearmed. Its cutoff18:24:55.122Z and native deadline 18:27:55.122Z were persisted before native startup. Native PID3767127, startToken272628440, DIRECT port8538, actual guest Workers1+2, real ticks, Normal/Original/Michael. The eighth confirmation was viewed before accepting; settled original eighth geometry, six blue/three gray, arrows, target and Moves96 matched the validated read-only model. The62 suggestions were consulted read-only; every selection and settled slide was personally reviewed and individually sent.

Native finished18:18:09.418Z after1213.060s, 405.705s before the gameplay cutoff. All110 DOWN intents have unique nonces, prearmed release, consumed receipts, independent UP ACK and actual release-child wait0/bothEOF. Fresh full-scene age at DOWN never exceeded18.653s. All108 non-final actions have post-release batch progress; final choices await native lifecycle evidence. No UNKNOWN, replay, after-cutoff gameplay, input auto-sequence, guest/media/config/physics/clock write or timeout occurred. Read-only samples and ordinary guest UI effects are separate from prohibited state writes.

Actual native, watchdog, supervisor and durable outer waits all exited0 with separate stdout/stderr EOF; watchdog exited on actual native wait without firing. The launch tool's direct child also has an actual separate-EOF wait. The external exec tool exposes combined output, so its separate EOF status is unknown, not inferred. Quit evidence is distinct from harness timeout. Native process absent, port8538 closed. No box was created: ID/expiry null, state NOT_CREATED, stop N/A.

Provenance and evidence

Original loaded module SHA256: c94ccf1b179f18bd4b47867445afed8cef2f1393b19aabfd259c7f3b94a7be09. Launch source base 204b0adcd8cdf405a808e2080fbe1962971762f8, with Git binary patches for relevant dirty/new source. Controller used throughout original: fc6c1334ac6454d95b2ce3d0bfc6f5f7837fa49ccab4969dea31012bd63d4c2d; supervisor 5c3b67add267af04376d84060ef8760c67eb054d9de69019ad272db51be3678f. All101 actually loaded source files matched at postflight. Broad1674 source pins disclose the concurrently changed, unloaded tools/forsaken-controller.py; this was not used by LMarbles. All87 media/CRT hashes matched; all86 manifest file sizes, hashes and VFS paths were checked. Original level SHA256 remains f6cf4f13a52e8b2c52aac714dc02a70770297c627f27b5510d7dd228af1d30f8.

Only16 named result PNGs are retained, each CRC/inflate/SHA verified; intermediate review captures were hashed then removed. Compact native logs, action journals, waits, media/source pins and Git patches remain. No source tree/module/media copy, frame series or archive was made. Prior1200s timeout and terminal files were read-only and remain unchanged. The failed action spelling mouse: was rejected by the whitelist before intent/arm/DOWN, then corrected to the ordinary mousedown: command; it was not an UNKNOWN or replay. A read-only sample filename collision after tally also refused overwrite and was reissued under a new name.

Next work would require a separately authorized native route through the chapter prerequisites to unlock Puzzle9. This task stops after publishing its reserve fix, Puzzle8 clear/tally, native Quit and precise Puzzle9 blocker.