Mad Bomber original SDL error consumer — 2026-10-24
Historical source last updated, 2026-10-24. Runtime and implementation claims below describe that dated source; see current app notes and source for subsequent changes.
BLOCKED: the consumer gap is not closed. Original SDL attach/unpacking and consumer identification succeeded. The next native execution was refused by fresh memory admission (2,384,236,544 bytes available; 2,684,354,560 required). No unchanged retry followed. The new executable fixture has passed syntax, exact input identity, and source/module rejection checks; its native consumer/output/bounds/stack oracle and output negative control have not run. No production fix is established or proposed.
Identified original consumer
The unmodified 86,016-byte original SDL.dll, SHA-256
55eced17cf8a9b7acc671cc307503de847a3c36fdafafe14cee7917433cfe410, is UPX-packed. The historical loader mapped it at guest 0x503000; its original entry at
0x53a130 executed and the loader reported DllMain EAX=1. The loader restores its
caller's state afterward: inspect-result.json EIP/ESP/EAX describe that restored
caller, not a consumer return. This was a native DLL initialization probe, with
no gameplay, EXE startup, window or audio playback.
The retained post-attach bytes identify internal native routine RVA 0xcff0,
91 bytes through its RET at 0xd04a. It is not an exported C/stdcall function:
the operation label arrives in EAX, and MMRESULT is the first stack argument. The authentic caller at RVA 0xd2c5 pushes EAX (waveOutOpen's return), loads EAX
with the original waveOutOpen() label, calls 0xcff0, and removes four argument
bytes. The callee returns with plain RET. The fixture sets EAX explicitly through
the VM's normal host ABI and checks this caller-cleanup convention; it does not
pretend this address is a public SDL API.
The routine allocates 256 local bytes, formats %s: through its original CRT
import, computes the prefix length, and calls IAT RVA 0x2324c with
(MMRESULT, buffer+prefixLength, 256-prefixLength). Original UPX import metadata
at RVA 0x35746 gives relative IAT offset 0x22210 from UPX's destination
base+0x1000. The 16th name is WINMM!waveOutGetErrorTextA, hence slot 0x2324c. It then calls native SDL_SetError RVA 0x14430 with %s and the local message. Public SDL_GetError exports native RVA 0x14400. Exact bytes, original caller,
import metadata, relocation operands and focused disassembly are retained beside
this report. The complete 237,568-byte mapped snapshot stays in the task root,
sealed by hash; it is evidence only and never an execution input. Recovery always
starts from the original packed DLL.
Fixture and present evidence
test/test-madbomber-sdl-error-consumer-candidate.js
checks a sealed 41-file historical host/PE/loader closure, the original DLL and
the exact normal module before compilation. It executes the packed attach entry,
compares all consumer bytes while normalizing only four actual relocated operands,
resolves WinMM and SDL_GetError through public GetProcAddress, and requires the
original consumer IAT slot to equal the public WinMM address.
The pending native oracle invokes the identified internal routine with supported
MMRESULT32 and two real operation labels. It expects the original local message
and SDL_GetError text to contain The audio format is not supported., checks
termination, untouched trailing bytes in the 256-byte local buffer, the return
sentinel and caller argument, guest ESP, terminal EIP=0 and no unexpected yield. This does not induce or assert a waveOutOpen failure. The original routine's
unbounded sprintf prefix is preserved; arbitrary oversized labels are outside
this fixture. It does not assert robustness for overflowing native labels.
--reject-output changes only the expected text's final word capitalization. It must fail at the native SDL consumer output oracle after real execution;
an identity rejection, loader failure or resource denial cannot count as that
negative control. This control remains pending, so there is no consumer PASS.
Executed checks:
- Original attach: exit0, 0.155s wall, 0.141087s child CPU, fixed shared 512MiB arena/oldspace512, fresh MemAvailable3,298,598,912, no output limit, group absent and explicitly reaped. Output146 bytes. No original DLL or module patch.
- Fixture syntax and
--verify-only: exit0; 41 files/2,512,870 bytes also match exact historical Git blobs. No native compilation/arena in these checks. - Wrong expected source and module: exit1 at their respective identity assertions, before compilation. Raw stderr and terminal receipts retained.
- Actual modified historical host fixture file: exit1 naming that source input; original bytes restored and rehashed. No DLL or wasm mutation was used.
- Offline recovered-byte validator: PASS; changed consumer byte, caller convention byte, and imported name each rejected. These controls test retained-byte identity, not native consumer output.
- Next native probe: memory denial before child creation.
identify-denial.jsonretains expected/actual memory. The later consumer fixture was never launched.
Exact inputs and recovery
Input main donor HEAD 9183b84473507ffe7c0598725e080a821c747945; isolated task
branch task/madbomber-authentic-sdl-error-consumer-oct24. Historical host source
b41a7c5f4b752d1f0bdab1141a11d4fed4dc6f9a, normal module 1,879,746 bytes,
SHA-256 8fac39936b6df2418ad86cab118cef19a65a727f649fbc14c412b37818904686,
291 imports/layout9a3bc9149d58209c. Existing accepted producer01dfb0d982bcd2756ae4668ff90b18c1949ecb56
and independent96ce3d9ab4d741c4ab789dea89301d9f8d1f77e8 were verified before reuse. Their 17-seal producer/53-seal build/140-pin acceptance is reused unchanged;
neither the accepted API tests nor a build was repeated. The 41-file closure adds
the exact historical DLL loader to the accepted 40-file host/fixture closure. No current-main host code is mixed into the historical module.
python3 recover.py scratch/runs/<run-id>/madbomber-sdl-recovery READONLY_GIT_REPO PUBLISHED_TASK_COMMIT
python3 ROOT/supervise.py consumer heavy ROOT/test-madbomber-sdl-error-consumer-candidate.js --input-root=ROOT/inputs --binding=ROOT/source-binding.json --sdl=/home/user/wine-assembly/scratch/runs/20261018-madbomber-source/original/madbomber-0.2.5/SDL.dll --wasm=/home/user/wine-assembly-shadow-man-span-static-canonical-oct23/build/wine-assembly.wasm