Maelstrom retained probe technical review, 2026-10-24

Historical source last updated, 2026-10-24. Runtime and implementation claims below describe that dated source; see current app notes and source for subsequent changes.

Independent source and provenance review

identities.json records verification of the coordinator's four pinned input hashes against immutable Git blobs and donor files. All 25 candidate evidence seals matched their actual immutable Git blobs. Historical source was recovered with read-only git show b41a7c5…:src/PATH and checked against the supplied lengths/hashes. The historical runner was independently recovered at d8cd8c54…:test/run.js, not equated with current exports. The actual original 24576-byte SDL_net.dll matched its pinned SHA-256, and its 96-byte window matched the candidate extraction. The standing 1879746-byte native module matched SHA-256 8fac39936b6df2418ad86cab118cef19a65a727f649fbc14c412b37818904686.

The candidate's limits are sound on source review: the original prefix is MOV EBP,EAX; CALL EDI; the breakpoint follows that CALL. Its generic interior instruction example does not explain the original game. A passive head count does not establish target execution or 972 native API calls. The historical zero-target cause, EDI target/return and errno remain UNKNOWN. The retained candidate native log is prior evidence, not this worker's fresh acceptance.

The executable probe contains direct live assertions for wrong target evidence, blocking yield, counter totals, breakpoint skip-once/reentry, cached successor entry and benchmark chaining. Its cheap test alone does not run native code; this review does not promote that test or prior logs into live native acceptance.

Exact candidate-tree checks

On the byte-unchanged candidate tree, the single supervisor ran:

The focused suite passed, including wrong halt/EIP/readback and removing each target-evidence guard. The existing unchanged boundary suite passed its seven rejecting mutations, watchpoint/anchor/export checks and finite no-hit control. Their underlying exact Node argv and terminal/cleanup records are retained. No merged tree exists to test.

Independent live contradiction control and worker fixture error

independent-native.cjs checks the exact candidate source hash, inserts one uniquely anchored control in memory, and invokes the real candidate probe once against the retained module. No candidate file was edited. This single invocation uses the same fixed 512 MiB arena and real native exports as the candidate.

The added control places a pending blocking yield at the exact breakpoint. Its assertions require: halt5 before counting; resume returns halt4 and count1 without decode or EBP change; next entry halts5 again; wrong requested target cannot invoke the read callback. These assertions preceded the eventual failure. Because the probe prints its rows only after full success, there is no retained row log for these controls. Their completion is an execution-order deduction from the later assertion location, not independent per-row output evidence.