Neverhood COMMCTRL candidate rejected — 2026-11-14

The repository-recorded Windows 98 SE OEM candidate is not the required companion for original Neverhood COMCTL32. Its NE module name is COMMCTRL, but its complete export table lacks Cctl1632_ThunkData16. This closes the authorized source route with a concrete dependency mismatch. No native connection operation, installer rerun, UI, or connection success is claimed.

Evidence: scratch/runs/20261114-neverhood-commctrl-connection/result.json.

Verified source and extraction

No existing matching local media or companion was found. The only downloaded OS source was the already recorded Windows 98 Second Edition OEM X05-29232. The complete ISO matches both recorded properties:

The recorded BASE4.CAB starting point follows additional BASE/NET/DRIVER cabinets and PRECOPY cabinets, beyond the described WIN98_21–74 range. Initial partial-chain extraction produced no companion; those warnings are retained. Completing that same ISO's chain recovered the file. A bounded single-cabinet listing of the staged cabinets identified its unique actual member in WIN98/PRECOPY1.CAB, not BASE4 itself. A second extraction using cabextract -s -q -F commctrl.dll directly on PRECOPY1 produced identical bytes without merging cabinets. PRECOPY1 SHA-256 is 81aa96efa1c0bdc665e46738f9c72439e46360193a6d7c5574c794aad41a25cf.

The minimal recovery recipe from the verified ISO is:

7z e -y -oDEST scratch/media/win98se-oem-x05-29232.iso win98/PRECOPY1.CAB
cabextract -s -q -F commctrl.dll -d DEST DEST/PRECOPY1.CAB
sha256sum DEST/commctrl.dll

Only COMMCTRL was expanded from the cabinets. No stock OS binary is committed or deployed. The rejected file is isolated at scratch/media/neverhood-commctrl-candidate/commctrl.dll; it is absent from scratch/win16-system/commctrl.dll and was never selected for execution.

Exact mismatch

The recovered file is 48112 bytes, SHA-256 070d5cd5fc011e5de48fda3ce093e75a85c6bd1b36187272bc75581e7cf6fc12. It has an MZ/NE header, module COMMCTRL, description COMMCTRL - Custom controls, and 21 named entry points. The repository's NE entry parser and an independent bounded resident/nonresident name-table walk agree: the required data export is absent. A complete byte scan also finds no LS01, SL01, or LB01 marker. Consequently there is no exported thunk header or actual companion checksum to validate; its checksum is recorded as null, never inferred from the module name.

The pinned original 577808-byte COMCTL32 retains SHA-256 28a41e6a35c4509924a32a99841a815cf49e1d3ee6912ec26a823e45472edfa4. Its unique LS01 header at file offset 430828 independently confirms checksum 0x1e9a, LB01, and relay offsets 0x24 / 0x44, agreeing with the predecessor's actual parked six-argument request.

Scope and next boundary

Per the task's mismatch stop condition, the released predecessor primitive, request, tests and census remain uncommitted and unchanged by this task. Relevant incoming tracked and new-file patches plus their exact Git baseline are recorded in the run; no source tree archive was made. No foreign WIP is published. The reduced transaction fixture remains outside this stopped route; its predecessor missing-import failure is not relabeled as passing.

Validation covered complete ISO identity, single-cabinet byte equality, NE module/entry/name tables, absence of required thunk markers, and the pinned original contract. This is a documentation-only publication; no production code or build output changed and no emulator/full build was run here. The last actual original boundary remains the predecessor's Missing NE image COMMCTRL, before UI. A matching, provenance-backed companion is still needed before persistent binding/lifetime and QT/FT work can proceed.

All extraction/download children have independent finite deadlines, actual waits and both-pipe EOF receipts. No screenshot, input, browser, or box was created. Box ID none; state NOT_CREATED; expiry null; stop receipt N/A.