Quake II production observation invalidation, 2026-11-08
Closed a concrete defect in 629a84ab: actual NodeWorker reset, reload and trace
disarm could leave earlier point observations marked valid until another
log_block callback. Snapshot retrieval also missed replaced native code when
no further callback occurred. The opt-in production attachment now invalidates
before these operations and checks its owner, memory and native pins on pulls.
Exact identity remains UNKNOWN.
Evidence: scratch/runs/20261108-quake2-exclusive-observation-2258/.
No game/browser/Chrome, remote, box, original retry or other agent was used.
Production change
The NodeWorker installs a plain, frozen facade over its actual CPU exports
before handing exports to loaders or other production helpers. Every export
except run and an explicit small register/address-read whitelist invalidates
existing observations before invoking the function. This includes
init_thread, load_pe, set_trace_esp, register setters and arbitrary calls
through readExports. Unknown exports conservatively invalidate; a name
beginning with get_ is insufficient to grant an exemption.
run retains bounded entry/return/failure counts, and an exception invalidates
before propagation. A returned CPU block is never called a completed native
load. Actual local and brokered host imports except log_block invalidate
before invocation, including suppressed diagnostic imports. These checks do
not depend on caller-authored continuity, writer or completion booleans.
Setup operations before the first observation are recorded without staling nonexistent evidence. Once invalidated, records cannot resume after trace rearming. Events retain only the latest 32 bounded descriptions and a saturated counter; records retain their existing 32-record bound. The observer writes no guest state. Execution, import results and exceptions retain their existing paths. Default remains off; no backend/configuration/timeout/clock/input change or new trace mode was introduced.
Worker init retires the previous observation before changing bindings or
attempting instantiation. Status returns at most one retiredObservation,
including when the replacement initializer fails, alongside the current
observation. This records actual instance/binding retirement, without claiming
that structured-clone object equality identifies underlying shared storage or
module bytes. Enabled replacement starts with no acquired points; disabled
replacement returns no current observer. Empty evidence is no longer marked
as valid point observations. Pulls revalidate actual pinned native bodies and
owner/memory even when tracing has stopped.
Offline executable coverage
node tools/quake2-exclusive-observation.test.cjs reuses the owning queued
fixture in tools/quake2-owning-load-witness.test.cjs, the unmodified shipped
CPU and actual shipped NodeWorker command/import dispatcher. It executes the
native acquisition CMP/JNE and source observation at 0x4118d9 with the accepted
explicitly authored 160-byte source. The use arm executes original table and
headnode code through RET, returning EAX4948. Fixture register changes now
invalidate the earlier acquisition, so that use is architectural validation,
never acquisition-to-use continuity.
Seventeen off/on pairs cover acquisition, actual init_thread, actual
load_pe of the installed EXE, disarm, rearm, a mutating readExports call,
native-body replacement detected without another callback, reinit with a new
compiled module, replacement shared memory, missing module, missing memory,
actual CPU log_eip import, caller-forged coverage flags, missing trace,
external source-memory replacement, rejected execution arguments and native
use through RET. Each pair compares architectural state, result/error and the
complete direct guest-memory hash. Every fixture Worker is terminated and
awaited; independent parent deadlines precede execution. The execution-error
control is an actual WASM argument-conversion rejection, not a CPU trap claim.
The external source writer deliberately remains undetected as a historical
point invalidation: its current bytes differ from the recorded acquisition
hash, while allWriters, exclusiveOwner, instructions, completedLoad and
exactIdentity remain UNKNOWN. No certificate is issued for this negative.
Absent trace has zero points and invalid point status. Reset/disarm/rearm/code
controls also execute later native blocks and verify old record counts cannot
grow after invalidation. Worker-import regressions and the required locked
build are checked in this run.
Accepted full native loader/cache/altered-entity experiments are referenced
from 2244 and
2205, without identical reruns.
Their retained native-load-use.cjs SHA is
e6fde32e696e4b544eb188fef2380372f5884a3f68a07754a7e6fe7e0446c186.
Current CPU PATH/HASH and installed EXE PATH/HASH are retained in the focused
results/references; no module or media copy was made. This run preserves their
fixture I/O/free/format/link limitations.
Remaining limits and evidence
This is conservative production invalidation, not an exclusive execution barrier. The facade is installed by NodeWorker; standalone host/import attachments do not intercept their caller's direct export invocations. Internal WASM calls and stores, other Workers, main-thread shared memory writers, native allocation lifetime and fused block interiors remain uncovered. Snapshot pin checks are point reads and cannot exclude concurrent changes or an intervening replacement restored before observation. No post-free completion point, full-load certificate, exact source at later use, edict ABA solution or gameplay inference follows. A trusted complete writer and completed-load path is still required before exact identity can change.
Command/log streams are gzip from their first stored byte. Inventory covers every regular file, with independent stored/original hashes, sizes, gzip CRC and exact file-set verification; its self seal is recorded externally on the messageboard. Recovery uses Git SHA and small owned patches, with no source archive, media/module copy, old/peer deletion or RAM gate. Disk samples exceed 1,500,000,000 bytes; no continuous-floor claim. The observable board watcher has an independent deadline and same-shell EXIT cleanup with actual waits and gzip EOF. Box NONE, state NOT_CREATED, expiry NULL, stop receipt N/A. Finish this single task, then STOP.