Stronghold review then ACK, 2026-11-05

This assignment follows published 9ac356cab12a5417487fa86a434c45cac4d3e7ff and 3d7ab1734d73e35c27dede0a6d01ab2df733a23e. Evidence: scratch/runs/20261105-stronghold-review-ack-original/.

The previous original stopped because the operator tried route-review-choose while install-route command 8 still awaited its capture-bound review. The production guard correctly refused and wrote no command 9. The operator plan now explicitly selects personal view/review, then waits for successful ACK, then permits consideration of the next existing command. A rejected ACK is terminal. The existing mailbox and production review guards are unchanged. The local contract tests reproduce command 8 through pending review, review receipt without ACK, successful ACK and rejected ACK. No fixture sends controls.

The new assignment requires both final code/build releases before runtime admission, plus the prior exact MDK heavy/file release and ancestor-held exclusive /tmp/wine-local-runtime.lock. Chrome cutoff is 2026-11-05T01:20Z, cleanup 01:23Z, with unchanged 720s runtime, 60s bootstrap, 40s command/review, and 180s cleanup reserve. Box ID/state/expiry: NA; coordinator owns shutdown.

The historical 2,429-row manifest remains authenticated and preserved. Only named final corrective source/module and passive helper amendments are allowed; all 1,856 media rows remain unchanged. Final legacy publication is 17e09475ecaeaa47de76684df0a0518124a6e387, superseding the initial packing error in 8808ec112. The run's binding ledger records exact historical and prior-binding old/new SHA-256, published provenance and reasons. Shared modules are used at existing paths and are never restored or copied.

The remedy was published as 54add0d4a307cd7eb3645a17c4bcf75ef62e34cb before the original. Both final dependency releases and exact prior normal cleanup were independently verified before acquiring the exclusive runtime lock.

Git is the source archive: exact commit SHA, relevant binary diff and new-file patches are retained. Existing game/media/module inputs are referenced by path and SHA-256. No snapshots, tars, module copies, npm, subworkers, boats, public deployment or other games are used.

The explicitly admitted final identities are:

Path Prior 9ac356cab SHA-256 Final corrective SHA-256
src/09ab-handlers-d3dim-core.wat 5c892770004355099d016e301ff73366a560237d681faf0cd3c6bd3aa8e4fc07 dbcf489a787b4f399eadc926e13336976d6eb0cc30ffed5c8c360af5b496a75a
build/wine-assembly.wasm 018c94ffbde8c857587c25c860db988d603d0662df9a18901f00c183af7493cd e620f3adfc2850580004e204bc1fea495844e942806866f8ada24c215212e412
build/wine-assembly.compat.wasm 4e684af48e4ec06ae8aada0d5cd2b522345a7a51b8ed89988d4d8fa0d75ea7c2 66b37bd76da5a7b49c063b4eb0d44c898aaf00ff41e000a6fbd87c01edc136c8

All three come from the named final corrective publication: anchored subpixel RGB placement with the original literal SIMD packing policy. The unchanged passive observer remains from a6d78555b; the local helper is the published 9ac356cab implementation plus this assignment's review/ACK plan, final-release checks and finite authorization. Its exact old/new hashes are in the ledger. The MDK2 validation tools do not occur in the preserved Stronghold manifest or its sealed retained-helper closure; their release serializes the shared build. No unrelated JS file is silently admitted or rehashed.

Both final dependencies are now released: legacy 17e09475e and MDK2 2c8c7cc1fd353af2df2f7c1b3d3240bb40c69c1b. This worker's subsequent required locked full build passes and reproduces both literal final module hashes. The local, route-recognition and passive-observer suites pass; the full composed local entry checks all 2,429 filesystem rows and actual HTTP responses with plain Puppeteer and independent public/native spawn prohibitions, zero Chrome. Nine public-entry stale-manifest, prior-pair and changed-byte negatives reject before launch. The final-input local test uses the actual current release rows and an explicit private fixture flock. This is offline evidence, not original presentation or gameplay evidence.

The one original ran from 00:48:34Z to 00:53:10Z. Every one of its 25 fresh checkpoint PNGs was personally viewed before further control, with hashes in personal-capture-inspections.jsonl. Command 8's existing capture-bound review was submitted at 00:51:35.216Z; its successful ACK arrived at 00:51:35.343Z; command 9 was issued at 00:51:39.256Z. Thus the previously failing operator sequence is corrected in an actual original, without weakening review guards. ChooseType and Custom Game hover reviews, and the balanced ordinary gesture, also completed their existing ACK paths.

The first surfaced command failure was command 13, route-arrival, at step 10,304: first unexpected natural scene: unknown (00:53:10.383Z). The fresh browser/route-native-boundary-8.png was personally viewed: sword/shield background, “Not available in the demo”, and red/yellow/blue numbered circles. This partial setup frame grants no readiness. There was no command 14, preset, Start, world control or second original attempt.

The same owning-worker history does contain actual native progress. In browser/preset-attachment-87.json, the original callback argument 2 requests scene 20, setup and callback return, then one complete draw proceeds through entry 0x4292c0, clock/update/late-clock/timestamp/epilogue, and actual saved caller return at decimal PC 5149135. Sequence 38–47 spans native boundaries 32,262,225–35,434,368. Entry/late times are 162315/164315; the stored timestamp becomes 164315 and refresh changes 1→0. Fade remains 32, direction remains -3; this is not proof of a completed fade. A second draw is pending at stop. All 85 retained native reports preserve their earlier record prefixes. The final report has 36,763,512 boundaries, below the unchanged 50M/360s limits, and no native observer fault. It contains zero surface events: source/target and HRESULT, operation-to-upload and renderer completion remain unproved.

Offline analysis found an earlier passive host-observer failure that the controller did not surface as a command rejection. Its first report, browser/host-presentation-0.json, is unsupported-or-unobservable, fault stale/unknown host capture, frame 0, sequence 0, with no records. The first pre-gesture capture came before any observed normal renderer frame. The production factory correctly rejected that capture and uninstalled its hooks; the controller persisted the terminal report and unknown link without throwing. Consequently later gesture/arrival ACKs did not establish host presentation. This earlier fault was discovered only after the original had stopped; the run must not be described as having stopped immediately upon that passive fault.

host-first-capture-replay.cjs reproduces the exact frame-zero fault through the real controller and serialized factory in a plain page VM, with no Chrome or game. A separate ordinary upload/repaint before capture passes the capture bracket while granting no readiness. Both cases pass. Existing positive tests had produced a frame before first capture; the composed entry mock stopped at launch. This exposes a lifecycle/fault-propagation gap, not permission to relax the frame or review guards. No production amendment was made after the original. The next work is an offline repair of that lifecycle and terminal fault propagation, plus examination of the exact unknown partial setup frame. Any future original needs separate authorization.

actual-evidence-summary.json and audit.log verify 1,058 actually served responses against exact pins, 161 contiguous 64-step transport ACKs, all 25 personal inspections, the command-8 review/ACK ordering, and no command 14. The actual compiled and slot-0-delivered canonical module is the final e620f3ad… module above. Final input is empty, active input null, mouse mask 0; the frozen 16ms cadence and all continuous guards remain intact. No timer drive, forced render, cap raise, reset or queued-input completion claim occurred.

Normal Browser.close followed the surfaced command failure. Chrome PID 1570178/startticks 188692357 exited with code 0, signal null at 00:53:10.640Z. Cleanup verification at 00:53:27.522Z proves that exact Chrome, Node 1570155/startticks 188692178 and flock 1570154/startticks 188692178 are absent; HTTP 34441 and DevTools 39957 refuse connections; the exact profile has no users and is absent; the external runtime flock is available. Local heavy ownership was released at 00:53:36Z. Box ID/state/expiry are NA; shutdown ownership remains with the coordinator.

Final validation: focused local/release-contract (42 negatives), route and observer suites; full actual composed entry 2,429 filesystem plus 2,429 HTTP checks with independent public/native spawn prohibitions and zero Chrome; nine public-entry negatives; full locked build reproducing the released module pair; two host lifecycle replay cases; and the retained actual-evidence audit. These pass with final inputs. Ordinary gameplay and completed presentation remain unproved; this assignment ends at the concrete failures above.